technology

Pro: They seem at least sympathetic to Palestine.

Con: This mostly just materializes as them using the blight of the Palestinian people to advertise their product. At least from what I can tell from the website. The only reference to material support for Palestinians I can find is that when you donate (not when you pay for a subscription) to the company they direct a small part of it to "Supporting Palestinian liberation and other resistance movements worldwide".

using "16X" less energy

I don't really know what they mean by this. They use a lighter version of an almost one year old model. It's probably using 16x less energy than something I guess?

among other claims and says it was built by 2 Syrian engineers

I don't really see a reason to doubt that.

Yeah I think it was being boosted by the Tech4Palestine org, which made me lose all respect for them.

Frankly everything about this is silly. Starting from the fact that - unless this is an op - there's no way these guys had the resources to train a new model from scratch, so this is most likely a fine-tuned, reskinned open-weights model like Qwen or Deepseek.

The "using X percent less energy" claim already smells of bullshit since they don't tell you the baseline: 16X less energy than what? Also, unless these two people somehow made massive advancements in the most crowded field of the moment, the energy savings they claim just come from the underlying Chinese models which are more efficient by themselves (so these guys would be stealing credit).

The claim that "Your data stays yours, always encrypted" is straight up a lie. Encrypted LLM inference is theoretically possible (look up Fully Homomorphic Encryption), but years away from being usable or commercially viable. In other words your data has to be decrypted before being input into the LLM, so these guys can read your chats. It's the same reason Proton caught a lot of shit when they launched Lumo, their chatbot: it's their only product that isn't end-to-end encrypted, breaking with their overall product proposition. Chatbots are a privacy nightmare if they're not running locally, and anyone telling you otherwise is a liar.

The part about "Amplifying marginalized voices" is also ridiculous... They fine-tuned it to be woke? It really sounds like the woke version of Musk playing with Grok to make it behave more like a Nazi. I wouldn't be surprised if they just gave it a system prompt espousing some vague progressivism and called it a day.

As a cherry on top, the idea of funding humanitarian causes with a product that is famously a money pit is hilarious. Every AI company is setting billions in venture capital on fire trying to make an insanely expensive to run product viable, but these guys somehow figured out how to make it sustainable and even have surplus to fund ethical causes with? Come on...

I try to give every milligram of benefit of doubt to projects that claim to be pro-Palestine, but this one is just too full of bullshit.

Cool name — at least, cool because it's one of the few Arabic words I know, ثَوْرَة thawra 'revolution' — but it does smell like bullshit to me. I haven't read the FAQ yet, though.