this post was submitted on 28 Apr 2026
170 points (86.6% liked)
science
26780 readers
1214 users here now
A community to post scientific articles, news, and civil discussion.
dart board;; science bs
rule #1: be kind
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Real answer: yes, it's as dead as anyone can be. 2 seconds after your death, your body isn't decaying yet, but that doesn't make you alive. Bodies kept in the freezers didn't decay but still, are not alive at all.
If the mantis didn't suffocate somehow, it would die of hunger or old age.
I guess the question is, what distinguishes a “dead” cell from a “live” one if it is not in decay? What makes this Mantis impossible to revive?
All that makes reviving any dead animal impossible plus much more.
The amber only protects the outer layer, I would assume that everything inside is already a dried pulp (but I am guessing).
Same reason CPR works right after someone drowns but not after they've been underwater a week...
You see, every cell has a "powerhouse" that turns stuff, including oxygen, into energy.
They keep a store of oxygen and food in every cell, respiration removes the waste and delivers resources.
Cut off respiration, and things start to shut down. Higher order systems first, and individual cells last.
That's why sometimes CPR works, but it took so long that the brain was deprived of oxygen and suffers damage. Everything was deprived of oxygen, but the most complicated shit needs the most and runs out first.
An insect can be "brought back" after a much longer time than a human without problems, but there's still a clock before each cell runs out of "on hand" resources and die. Whether or not decay happens after is completely separate.
For the absolutely most basic things like virus or bacteria, or even water bears, they've adapted to be able to spring back after a long time, sometimes thousands or tens of thousands of years...
But a mantis is just too complicated. Especially after 30 million years.
Most of the proteins within the cell would denature over (a fairly short) time, which means all the cell functions would fail. The cell membranes would also rupture and dissolve or rot eventually. Only the hard keratin exoskeleton would remain reasonably intact.