Do you not trust American made games?
Privacy
A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.
Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.
In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.
Some Rules
- Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn't great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
- Don't promote proprietary software
- Try to keep things on topic
- If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
- Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
- Be nice :)
Related communities
much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)
I should not say crazy so much as racist. The idea of a westerner calling China a "well known surveillance state" without irony is farcical. What exactly are you worried will happen?
yes
yes, you are
But not just China...
I would say you are not paranoid, but the reasons you have equally apply to non Chinese Games and social networks.
So to be consistent, either not play Games and get off of social networks, or do it.
China isn't any more of a surveillance state than the US and Europe already. Why would a Chinese game be any worse than the ways you're spied on by people that can actually do something with your data? Wherever you live, assuming it isn't China, your data is already being collected by people far more capable of doing something about it if they found something they didn't like, and far more interested in doing so.
Let's face it, the CPC almost certainly doesn't care about you, and it would be better for the PRC to have your data than your local government and corporations, that do care far more about you. I don't see why fearing a developing socialist state so much makes any sense.
My question for the yankees who worry about "Chinese technology spying" on them: Can the CPC send death squads to your house?
I hate liberals so much it's unreal.
Im not meant to harbor hatred in my heart, but here we are living in the hater multiverse. When in Rome...
Am I being to paranoid ?
No, you are not enough paranoid if you don't have the same or worse concerns about games developed in western countries. e.g. five eyes alliance.
I think this is true for all games that access the internet. However, it seems an especially large number of Chinese games that make it to the West require an internet connection to function. Sometimes it makes sense (multiplayer mechanics, gacha, etc.), sometimes it doesn't at all (some relatively popular single-player RPGs with no online play require a connection just to make a save file, for example).
This is just to say I understand people being concerned if all they see are these Chinese online-required games everywhere when they can also find some random completely offline game made in America, Europe, Japan, etc. just as easily (or even a game with an optional online mode that can be disabled without the game breaking).
Western games do this tol, though, even where it doesn't make sense to. It isn't a China specific thing, and China has less of an ability to do anything malicious with that data than your local governments and corpos.
China isn't going to spy on you any more than American games. Not saying they won't, but like, you have a phone? That's more of a privacy issue by itself than almost any game you could play.
It's crazy to trust any closed source software.
Are you also concerned over the Western states surveilling you from the games?
I have a feeling this person has never considered doubting Western countries. Whether they know it or not, it's the result of Western exceptionalism. The average Westerner believes their countries and institutions exist for good, and their enemies are inherently evil
The efficient propaganda, when the lambs can't even say they were fed with it their entire lives
The Chinese government should be no more a concern for privacy than any other government. The only one worse than any other for you specifically is the one in which you reside, which would be able to make the best use of that data. The only exception is if you're a dissident or target of a foreign country.
Security and economic contribution are a different beast.
Worse for an western gamer that big western companies logs their data, than that China do it, in China nobody gives a fuck of personal data from western users. Different for Chinese gamers.
There's always the risk of spying if a game requires an internet connection, no matter who published it, but unless you plan to be in China later on, there's not much that Chinese companies (or authorities, if that is of concern) can do with the data collected on you.
I suppose some company could sell that data back to a US firm in a roundabout way. Anyway, take what I say with a grain of salt since I've hardly played or looked into any games requiring an internet connection.
Crazy to game on anything you trust with important data in general. Same for internet browsing-in-general though. Good Luck.
Yes you are crazy. China doesn't give a shit about you, if they really want your data they can just buy it from your government or one of the many corporations that are all verifiably spying on you and selling your data.
Um no, any propreitary game with an internet connection and privileged access to your computer can and will spy on you, your goal should be sandboxing, limiting permissions and information access and using a zero trust policy.
What country a proprietary application is from doesn't matter, any private company can and will spy on you for profits, be it Chinese or American, even better if the courts are corrupt and run on cash.
The US can just as easily launch a centralized surveillance campaign, and likely does through the NSA, do not trust any proprietary application just because it's from a "civilized" or "developed" country, they are but the same as long as they are chasing profits.
Steam used to upload your whole resolver cache to Valve (So they could sidestep things not showing up in history when you use private-browsing). And they're mandated to share everything they have on you with the NSA. So if you're coming at this from a "I'll trust Steam but not Wukong" angle, then yes, you are unreasonable. If you're coming at this from a "All these private Chinese companies have insane privacy policies and send me hundreds of cookies, I'm not trusting anyone they work with!" angle then that's completely reasonable. Closed source software is never safe, and capitalism doesn't reward treating your customers well.
I remember when tiktok was being advertised as something to fill the vine vacuum and it looked cringe as hell and just obvious spyware and I thought there's no way anyone would install that.
Here we are.
Also it's hilarious that Microsoft were finally on a winner with vine and they just scrapped it.
Yes. They're state-sponsored propaganda, but unless you can identify legitimate security risks, you're just operating on "feelings."
Honestly, this is probably not the best instance to ask this question on. It is well known for downplaying or outright denying anything negative the Chinese government does. If I were you I would ask elsewhere if you want more nuanced answers.
Anything's possible when you make shit up

I disagree pretty heavily with this, you're more likely to see invented fantasy on other instances and more nuanced reality on Lemmy.ml when it comes to China.
Hahahahahahahaha

Ah yes, very nuanced
I don't see how that's funny

This is kind of proving his point tbh.
Go ahead and try explaining how, I could use a laugh
Paranoid? No. Racist.
If you were really paranoid, you'd trust no games, regardless of origin country.
I don't know what led you to believe this person is racist, but this is a massive leap in logic. There are plenty of reasons a person could be wary of the Chinese government that don't involve them hating the race of its people. Please be more considerate in the future.
Chinese government uses all tools at its disposal to broaden their range of influence in tech, including tracking and monitoring. Avoiding products backed by chinese government doesn't make one racist, the same as avoiding products with NSA influence doesn't make one anti-american.
Only avoiding Chinese products while giving NSA ones a parse does make them racist though
Bingo