Hot take, they're both good and which one I prefer is going to depend on the decor level of the area I intend for it. If it's going in, say, a bathroom with plain white walls and a basic sink, I'm going to want the white and brown to add more overt detail and spice up the area a bit. If it's going in a kitchen with a patterned backsplash and embossing on the front of the sink, I'm going to want the plain etched with a harmonious design so it complements the other details instead of competing with them for attention.
Edit: I see they're going in a shower, so I'd want the higher contrast so I can see it without my glasses on, lol

Evil doppelganger