this post was submitted on 20 Nov 2026
666 points (96.5% liked)
Technology
89964 readers
3389 users here now
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related news or articles.
- Be excellent to each other!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, this includes using AI responses and summaries. To ask if your bot can be added please contact a mod.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
- Accounts 7 days and younger will have their posts automatically removed.
Approved Bots
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Your comment is not reasonable.
Even today, with Internet and egalitarian laws and common literacy, living in a small village is not a pleasant experience.
And you can experience medieval society right now, in rural India or Afghanistan. At least you might read about it.
I don't know what view you are talking about, nothing locked and controlled, just the society around you.
Things locked and controlled are sometimes good , for example, when your fate is decided by the collective opinion of your village, they won't lynch you if there's control.
And in a medieval village they would lynch you if they wanted.
But again, living in a village in a developed country is still, after all those centuries, living in a village, people write things on how it is to live in a village.
Your comment is completely untrue. You're watching brave heart and playing chivalry thinking that's how it was. It wasn't.
People were not locked into a profession, if they had a good one they worked to keep it. People did all sorts of work and the need for a job which paid was actually not as important as working to secure food for you and your people. Community mattered more.
On top of that, because the community mattered, there wasn't mindless slaughtering, hangings and such violence you're asserting. That's literally ridiculous. Crime was both higher in some ways than today and actually much lower. They wouldn't lynch you if they wanted, such a dramatic belief of history you carry.
That's actually not medieval society it's modern society. Medieval society was very isolated and community oriented. The problems in Afghanistan and India you're talking to have a lot more to do with racism, inequality that evolves into anger, loss of community, and access to extremely dangerous weapons like guns. Those aren't things the medieval era struggled with. People were more homogeneous, they didn't travel much and didn't fully understand the inequality they faced especially since it wasn't the same level of predatory as the modern age. They didn't need to maintain an office job, car payments, mortgage, money for food. All of those were just daily chores.
And then battles? They were not gut spilling brutal massacres of gore and hate and violence. They were actually kind of slow. Troops were rotated out often, you didn't field the whole force at once that's stupid people gotta shit and eat and rest up for the fight later on. Soldiers would retreat once formations broke. If you wanna see what a battle looked like go watch a group of teenagers yelling at each other on the street before a fight and scale that up, then watch HEMA or Buhurt and recognize most fighters weren't professionally trained, you had guys with spears told to stand there and a couple really good fighters in walking tank suits. Both groups will get exhausted after 30 minutes of fighting.
You have a ludicrous view of history.
Very fucking strange, it seemed you do that and I'm trying to explain that people are not very nice when not checked.
... And competing in trade was an act of aggression, judged by how justified it was, and if it wasn't you were considered a thief. That's a specific fact about those medieval community values. That made sense in small isolated settlements and no market to speak of to alleviate supply and demand changes.
And there were not locked specifically , but they were not expected to just pick another way of life, that wasn't normal. I don't know where even specifically to send you, there's plenty of good historical fiction, but there's also plenty of literature from the times we are discussing, like Chaucer might help, or some of the Norse sagas for a different, but still quite similar society.
I don't even know why you are arguing this, if you think there was some better society that was "ruined by capitalism", that ain't it. Too stupid an idea anyway.
That's exactly what they are, isolated and community oriented places where a village mulla can say to the people that you insulted Quran and you get lynched within an hour. Plenty of real cases in our times. Plenty of such real cases described by travelers hundred years ago and two hundred years ago. And that's how it was in European villages.
Yes, damn right, literally being owned is not the same level of predatory. You are amazing.
Yes, of course they didn't understand the inequality, they were more equal than now, except in a medieval society it's not considered that two equal people can do the same things. In a medieval society you have your place, your family, your ancestors, your trade and can't just change to any other equal place. Even in cities, and of course you couldn't in villages. Nobody forces you, you'll just die from hunger because it'll be very hard to be accepted into some other "equal" place, accepting strangers was uncommon, and a stranger competing in some trade with a known local wouldn't have any clients. Even if theft accusation wouldn't happen and it could.
They did have jobs (just couldn't realistically change them), they did have debts, and due to less productive technologies owned less and owed more, and of course they did need to have money to buy food if they failed to grow food, they didn't live in communism, that's for sure.
They could submit into serfdom if they were freemen that couldn't feed themselves on their own. That didn't mean they wouldn't need money and work to live and care for themselves and pay debts, they just could submit into serfdom in exchange for something, like payout of their existent debt by their new master. One time.