Ask Lemmy

I'm not really going to respond to all that because I'd just be restating the same thing over and over. I'll focus on one point:

Yes I'm more than aware of how Cleaners of Venus distributed their music.

That's my entire point - they're a very much niche band essentially unknown in their time - and I would have never, in a million years - known about their distribution method, or known of them at all, if it wasn't on Wikipedia and on the internet and their music wasn't easily torrented or streamed.

Even if they were less niche, and sold their records in stores: stores are very very expensive, anything meatspace is very very expensive due to rent costs of the actual precious physical space, they have to make their stock count, and that means catering to the mass market.

If such stores even exist - which they essentially don't and when they did they were few and far between and not exactly record stores - more something like HMV, they catered to the mass market first because they are giant mega corps and dgaf about anything but the bottom line.

The internet - anyone could post anything there. Any music, any news about any new music, and anyone could access it from anywhere.

So If you literally believe that finding music is easier via counting on random zines and special orders in magical vinyl record stores that exist as far as I'm concerned - in fiction only, and when most countries in the world didn't even have such a concept, than via the internet which is available everywhere at all times to everyone globally, you're insane and I can't help you.

That is an insane, obviously incorrect position to hold and if you can't see that, you can't be made to see it with any arguments anyone could present.

I think that must be it because you made another truly psychotic claim here:

There was, let me check notes.... cassettes. Bands used to record music in their living room with a cheap 4 track, and put them on cassette.

Cleaners from Venus have 261k monthly listeners on Spotify. That means they'd need 216,000 cassettes. They'd also need the logistics and distribution to ship them all over the world to simply even come close to the reach they have now, to even be hypothetically obtainable.

Just because you lived in a shitty place, doesn't mean your experience was universal. The city I lived in was so small, we had a single bar that catered to everything outside of mainstream. Gay, goth, punk and metalheads... all in the same place. It was not uncommon to hear a Sepultra song, followed by Bauhaus or the Pet Shop Boys or Skinny Puppy.

Of course it's not universal. But it is more universal, because most of the world are not in one of like, three-ish Western European countries and the 10 or so sane cities in the United States. I'm sorry that causes your narrative of the world and how things used to be and/or are to be incorrect, but it's the simple truth.

What was universal? Top 40 hits played on TV and Radio. That was pretty much everywhere. That is - until the internet and now you could be a Wavves fan in Russia, and I'm sorry the thought is so offensive to you.