congrats everyone on your two free months of credit monitoring
Technology
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related news or articles.
- Be excellent to each other!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, this includes using AI responses and summaries. To ask if your bot can be added please contact a mod.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
- Accounts 7 days and younger will have their posts automatically removed.
Approved Bots
A certain subset of people: "B-but at least it stops kids seeing photos of dental decay!!!1111"
Anyone still defending age verification online is an idiot.
I don‘t think I‘ve ever seen someone defend it online but there were a few people laughing it off which is not much better.
Proofs the UK is a shithole as well funnily enough.
Nothing against the Brits but their government oh damn that's bad.
Wait til you see the next one.
:(
Yep. This is just the first. As long as individuals submit to these ID verifications, services which provide them will be highly targeted. I find it ridiculous that 1.5 million people actually submitted their info to access discord instead of finding a workaround or alternative. I can only imagine how many are gullible enough to verify on porn sites.
Just roll all the class actions into a UBI fund for the people
So, I looked at age verification - it was made clear photos were on device only and never transmitted.
If this turns out to be false, then the legal fallout would be apocalyptic.
(Edit: or not, see the comment by ambitiousprocess below)
These were photos submitted via the compromised support provider (Zendesk) via the Discord support portal.
Automated age verification via their partner (k-ID, which has its own issues) is a separate system, which was only available to some users. Other users had to contact Discord support manually and submit photo ID, which went through Zendesk, which was then compromised in this breach.
Additionally, for the automated process, it's the video selfie that's on-device and never transmitted, but photos of your ID and selfie photo are transmitted, just supposedly deleted afterwards. Those ones are *not included in this breach, as far as we're aware, as it's an entirely different third-party with wholly separate infrastructure.
Which is why you farm off stuff like this to third parties whenever possible
DiscordCorp will get a slap on the wrist and give people an offer of a free six months of discord turbo (so long as you provide payment info so it can auto-renew on month seven).
But ANY meaningful consequences will go toward Zendesk Corp for not doing what they were supposed to. And... then everyone will just use ZZendesk instead
Well, yeah. Discord isn't exactly at fault here, they're operating as best they can within the boundaries of a piece of legislation that could be best described as gods gift to the "I-told-you-so" crowd. This breach is exactly what everyone was warning would happen with the UK ID laws, and discord got stung first as they're one of the few companies trying to adhere to the law in good faith (which, yes, why in hell they're trying to do this is good faith is a very good question)
What legal fallout? Discord made users agree to new terms just a week ago that involves forced arbitration.
Forced arbitration clauses are not legal in many European jurisdictions, so "agreeing" to them didn't actually do anything.
Politicians: That's the point.
Joking aside, now that I think about it, what difference does does it make if companies are stealing infos and spying on you with government mandated age verification checks, and hackers stealing your government mandated age verification info? This just reinforces my view that governments (and companies) are nothing but glorified gangsters.
And this is why this provide xyz private information for verification bs should be illegal
And why any service asking it should be moved on from.
Pretty sure these people could have found a teamspeak, matrix, or mumble server without the requirement.
so instead of creating some kind of authorization system that would not require sending your private information to everyone the govt did nothing and instead put that responsibility on EVERY company. begs the question why rushing so much?
The department of Social security could have created some sort of public/private key pair to very age and DOB. But that's too much to ask for isn't it?
Have you seen the USA? UK? Russia? China? I really don't want the government making any system to tie internet to any identity. I really don't want any government having any role in the internet.
The fact that these photos and PII (personally identifiable information) were not destroyed after the verification process was certified is absolutely atrocious OpSec. I don't even care which of the two companies is ultimately responsible, because they are both responsible.
- Zendesk for their bad OpSec
- Discord for both outsourcing this AND not having contractual requirements to properly secure and destroy PII when it was no longer required.
I work in IT, and treat PII like it's dangerously radioactive, because in the digital world, it really is.
That's because you have ethics
"Apparently" only those who were challenging the verification results and uploaded awaiting reverification are affected.
Not that that isn't bad enough
That's why I used a picture of my anus for my age verification photo. The wrinkles are what sold it, I think.
this is why i dont give my ID to any service(obv including Discord) anymore.
The issue here is that age verification is mandatory in the UK, and not just for Discord.
Thank god I never gave them an image.
Hmm, I don't recall ever doing age verification for Discord. Were older accounts grandfather'd in, or is it currently limited by region or something?
I think it's a UK thing
They have been passing legislation to basically dox their citizens for them to gain access to the internet
It was obvious things like this will happen, unlike banks and government sites social media sites don't have strict cyber security requirements and they want these sites to have a government ID. It was a bad idea from the start.
Any time your account gets locked for age reason it requires it. So if you have never had an age lock it's unlikely you had to do it.
It's as easy as someone reporting you for being underage with no proof or even just saying "I'm 14 and what is this" as a meme to get locked tho.
Hell the auto flag system can hit you if you just talk like a kid sometimes.
More than half of them turn out to be AI
They're all screenshots from Detroit: Become Human
the only person who's allowed to verify my age is my cat because he won't stop being a dick about it
I’d like to use your cat verification system too.
I've criticized the sort of personal information that is allowed to be managed by banking entities in the cases of Accidental Americans, where people who have nothing to do with America except that they were born in the US have their data handled by private entities to be passed onto governments they've never been in. Public entities that should handle and be responsible for it in their actual home countries want to wash their hands off from them and there's too much money against too small of a minority for anyone to care about their rights. It doesn't matter how banks have consistently proven that they or their staff can act criminally, either.
At least here, it affects a lot more people so it will likely bring in the change and reform it needs, even if the sensitivity of this data is significantly less.
Gonna have to say, this guy is definitely gonna be screwed by this:
Keep on keeping on 👍
To the surprise of no one here. This is the first thing I think of when a system wants me to upload an ID.