Well Brave is a joke because of their scams and crimes so if you just pick literally anything else you're already ahead of the game
Privacy
A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.
Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.
In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.
Some Rules
- Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn't great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
- Don't promote proprietary software
- Try to keep things on topic
- If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
- Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
- Be nice :)
Related communities
much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)
Brave is a crypto bro sham that blocks external ads just to insert their own
Searx.space
You might need to try a few and cycle between them so you don't get fingerprinted though.
Brave is some Crypto-Bro stuff, i'd go with DDG or Kagi. At some point you could get a Junk-PC and run SearXNG on it
Still you wont build your own index, but you will pay for other api which will be behind SearXNG. So question is, what is the point here?
You may want to reconsider your stance on subscriptions if you're looking to degoogle and go towards more privacy. General stance in the community (if I remember right) is that if you're not paying for the product, YOU are the product. Meaning they will likely be sharing more information, even if inadvertently through ad networks and whatnot.
If it is on the internet, not self hosted, you are typically the product if you pay or do not pay.
de-googling is a process, it won't be perfect for a long time. No matter what many comments say, just starting with one or two things is already huge.
Both DDG and Brave Search are already an improvement. Go with the choice that causes the least resistance and then keep improving from there, as long as it works for you.
Striving for ideological perfection is a dead-end.
Striving for ideological perfection is a dead-end.
You can strive for it, you just need to understand it's a process that takes time and that there's inevitably temporary consequences along the way
You could also try the ddg lite version: no JavaScript, no ad, no ai https://lite.duckduckgo.com/lite
Oh, I just realized that I can set this up as my default search from the URL bar!
I already had DDG as the default search in Firefox, but I was slightly annoyed that it kept throwing in AI and other stuff if I searched from a private window or something. I just added DDG Lite as a new search engine (use "https://lite.duckduckgo.com/lite/?q=%25s" as the URL), and I set it to the default. We'll see how that works for me.
Why does no one mention Qwant, Mojeek, or Ecosia? Those are pretty good
Please don't mistake this for an endossement of DDG. But nobody trusts Mojeek's leadership, nobody can access Qwant because they block hardened browsers, and Ecosia's business model is selling your data.
If you have a VPS that can access Qwant and a way to transfer links between it and your general high risk VPS, Qwant might be a good option for a lot of users.
From a non-privacy perspective, if someone wanted to de-google for BDS reasons, I'd probably tell them to switch to Ecosia.
I didn't know about Mojeek leadership, I only recently discovered.
I access Qwant NP from Waterfox with hardened settings and extensions to block a lot of stuff.
Ecosia does currently use Bing & Google data for results (building an index with Qwant), but the data is anonymized/does not build personalized profiles while still creating value and funding for the company.
Startpage?
If you have the ability to selfhost then searxng is also a very good option.
I want to try hister by the same developer. It's so you can save search results and make your own engine.
I always recommend https://noai.duckduckgo.com/%s because I'm trying to find results without AI/LLM. Nearly all search engines, including Brave, have AI results as a default. Sure, I can disable the AI results in the engine's settings but it's reset the next time I open my browser.
If this is how they actively go against their own browser ethos, what makes you think they will stick to their search engine ethos.?
I recall the founder of DDG having some kind of CIA connection. Someone correct me if I am misremembering.
I'll share my unpopular stance. You can use Brave search from any browser, I use it with Librewolf. This way I get independent web index without any crypto-bro shit. So what is advantage over using DDG? Its that they actually have their own index so its not just a front for some megacorp.
When I was looking around for web search Kagi and Mojeek weren't as good. Maybe that is changed now. What I do know is that Google that I have on my work machine doesn't perform any better than Brave.
Waterfox is the AI-free way to go.
I prefer Startpage out of all of them, but lately been using Kagi’s APi along side my SearXNG instance and the experience has been quite enjoyable.
People don't like Brave, the company, or its founder. As usual, it's mostly politics.
You cant trust someone that sides with Trump
Nowadays it's always needed to use several search engines to fullfit a deeper research. If own or third party search index is irrelevant, every search engine handle it in a different manner. More important as this that the search engine don't logs your activity, this is given in most search engines, except Google, Bing, (Brave) and Yahoo. Startpage, Mojeek, Ecosia, Qwant, MetaGer, Swisscows (if you have childrens and need a Family safe search) among others, are very valid. Also usefull searches of specific pages (WolphramAlpha, Wiki, Forums, etc) and to add also analytic pages as search engine (Blacklight, VirusTotal, Webbkoll, etc), to check unknown URLs.
Does mojeek have its own index? I see in preferences you can choose where you get results from and brave is one option selected by default.
Options like qwant, ddg, swisscow, etc are also available. Are those any good? Do they use their own indexes? I know ddg doesn’t.
I do not want to be vilified for saying this, so I will echo what everyone else seems to be suggesting of DDG being a good degoogled search engine.
When I started to degoogle, personally do not remember what I was using DDG and ecosia probably. I hear ecosia has jumped into the AI game which I think is icky for what they are trying to do.
I later started getting into home labbing. I am in no way suggesting that you should jump into that right now, this is a rather expensive lifestyle, it starts with one project and you think oh fun what can I replace next? So the search engine I use now is searXNG, which I have set to pull from Bing, wikiepedia, and a bunch of smaller engines. I am just trying to say there are options for you to look into in the future. Not right now you are just getting out of the Google ecosystem
So the search engine I use now is searXNG
Ah you think darkness is your ally? You merely adopted the dark.
Heh, just making a silly joke. As a home labber, I imagine you're well across YaCy, so am just name dropping it for the newbies. Yacy, Hister etc etc.
Answering the OP -
Personally, I find myself either going directly to the sites I want, using RSS feeds or (gasp!) using my local LLM agents with MCP adapters, with something like Exa to fetch the info I want (or directly via PubMed etc).


(these are raw CLI; I need to wire this up to XMPP very soon so I have something that's a little less "Haxor" for the rest of the family to use)
More and more, I am mirroring the stuff I need offline, so that I can point my pet clankers at my local files, Kiwix archives, Recoll etc and then just one-click them open.




I have heard of Yacy, do not know why I choose not to use it. Maybe tonight I will be doing another deep dive into it.
It's sort of a pain in the ass...but worth a shot. Maybe.
I looked at it some more and thought yeah probably not.
+5 wisdom