this post was submitted on 20 Nov 2026
68 points (80.4% liked)

science

30028 readers
602 users here now

A community to post scientific articles, news, and civil discussion.

dart board;; science bs

rule #1: be kind

lemmy.world rules

founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
top 50 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] General_Effort@lemmy.world 2 points 4 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago)

Latest news regarding the Riemann Theorem ...

Joint statement by the Lean FRO and the Mathlib Initiative.

[...]

We have full confidence that Alpöge's proof of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct, and we congratulate him on this achievement.

Our rationale is outlined below.

https://leanprover-community.github.io/blog/posts/riemann-hypothesis/

[–] technocrit@lemmy.dbzer0.com 2 points 4 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago)

Wow they solved the most famous math problem just 2 days after their IPO flopped??!?!

What a coincidence lol. I can't wait for the verification...

[–] RecursiveParadox@piefed.social 5 points 7 hours ago

Appreciate the good discussion here.

[–] melfie@lemmy.zip 6 points 7 hours ago (1 children)

Are there any proofs this large created by competent mathematicians, or is a real proof typically significantly more distilled than 1.3GB?

[–] NoneOfUrBusiness@fedia.io 10 points 7 hours ago

The proof, expanded into text, spans 250k pages. Suffice it to say that no proof by a human is that large.

[–] groet@feddit.org 40 points 22 hours ago (2 children)

Hank green has a good video about this topic

The point is AI companies use mathematical proofs as a way to evaluate and improve their models. Its not about the proofs themselves, they are a side effect. They are also completely useless for the math community because nobody can understand them. The value of a proof is in the math you used to get there and usually a proof like this involves new math that can then be used to solve other problems. The AI proofs provide none of this. Mathematicians now know something is true or not but can not use that knowledge for anything.

[–] 14th_cylon@lemmy.zip 5 points 6 hours ago (3 children)

Mathematicians now know something is true or not but can not use that knowledge for anything.

look, i hate the slop machine built on stolen knowledge of humanity as much as the other person, but if you can be sure something is true or not, you can definitely use that knowledge, even if you do not understand the proof.

[–] thenextguy@lemmy.world 5 points 6 hours ago

I think they mean that mathematicians cannot themselves use this proof to prove other things, or gain new insights.

The Riemann hypothesis itself isn't very useful. It says something about the distribution of primes. But we've known for some time that all known primes fit the hypothesis, out to over a trillion of them.

[–] SpacetimeMachine@lemmy.world 3 points 6 hours ago (1 children)

Yea but it is still FAR less valuable than a proof where we actually understand the math behind it and know how to apply it to other problems. For many proofs just knowing they are true isn't all that useful.

[–] 14th_cylon@lemmy.zip 1 points 6 hours ago

Yea but it is still FAR less valuable than a proof where we actually understand the math behind it and know how to apply it to other problems.

there is no argument there

[–] jj4211@lemmy.world 1 points 5 hours ago

In this case, it was something that for all practical purposes was already presumed to be true, but not formally proven.

If it found an unexpected result, that could be useful knowledge, but this case is of no practical use compared to before the proof.

[–] peopleproblems@lemmy.world 21 points 21 hours ago (4 children)

Looking at it, it COULD be deconstructed to an actual, usable proof. If you had nothing but time on your hands. And that it held absolutely no bugs (1.3gb of code? Absofuckinglutely unlikely)

The bigger problem is that its confusing as all hell to the uneducated public. Its a proof in the sense that it technically proves the theorem. Its not a proof in that it must be able to be peer-reviewed. AI modeled proofs are intended for the AI. They cannot be peer-reviewed, thusly they are useless.

It is, however, fun to entertain the idea that a proof does exist, we just have more work to do to get there.

[–] Treczoks@lemmy.world 9 points 12 hours ago (1 children)

My son explained it to me. Basically those files are automatic proof files, and they are syntactically correct. But if you ever wrote a program, you'll know that getting it through the compiler without error messages does only get you so far.

According to him, they already found serious issues with the actual logic.

[–] partofthevoice@lemmy.zip 7 points 11 hours ago

When AI writes code, especially large code bases, it tends to be quite disorganized and unintelligible. It takes you all but 5 minutes to pick out 10 things that piss you off like, “why the fuck would it do that?” It’s complicated code, much more so than the domain is complex in its own right.

The “proof files” is just the codebase containing the code which in theory proves the theorem.

Nobody has the time to proof read that gargantuan piece of shit.

But the bigger point is: If a human had done it, then other humans would have been able to use the result. At least other field experts would find the text legible.

[–] someacnt_@lemmy.world 13 points 16 hours ago

I think it is just as likely that it exploits the Lean theorem prover. IIRC, its evaluation model itself is known to have logic holes for convenience reasons.

load more comments (2 replies)
[–] Eq0@literature.cafe 59 points 23 hours ago (3 children)

I am mad at this proof. Someone that did not understand what was going on (by his own public admission in his post) got a swarm of mechanical monkeys to try random things until they worked, and now we have an unreadable proof that the community needs to work to understand while getting no credit for doing the dirty and boring work

[–] snooggums@piefed.world 20 points 19 hours ago (1 children)

How do we know the proof is correct if nobody understands it?

Why should anyone spend the time verifying unreliable machine vomit?

[–] Eq0@literature.cafe 24 points 17 hours ago (1 children)

Because the proof as presented is a Lean program. Lean is a proof checking program, that means that this type of code runs only if the logic used is correct.

For example, you can write a proof of pythagora’s theorem and the code would run. But if you write a faulty proof (even if the final theorem is correct), the code doesn’t run.

About your second question, I agree with the sentiment, I will still answer the question unironically. Because if it’s in Lean it’s supposed to be reliable, and because we mathematicians are suckers for proofs, even obscure, poorly written stuff. We assume that a cool proof open the gate to new understanding of math.

[–] 14th_cylon@lemmy.zip 5 points 6 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago) (3 children)

Because the proof as presented is a Lean program. Lean is a proof checking program, that means that this type of code runs only if the logic used is correct.

and how do we know that the lean (i am hearing the word for the first time - this is not a sarcasm, but genuine question) is correct, in its design, lack of logical flaws and the implementation?

lot of the software where the exploit was found was considered reliable, because it worked on known and proven mathematical principle, until the exploit was found.

[–] jj4211@lemmy.world 5 points 5 hours ago

I'll just whip up a proof in lean to prove lean is correct

(I'm absolutely unqualified to have any opinion on any of this)

[–] napkin2020@sh.itjust.works 2 points 4 hours ago

The exported raw proof has been checked by several proof checkers, including Lean’s official kernel, the con-leche and con-ron checkers, and several independent checkers contributed by third parties and implemented in different programming languages. The checkers con-leche and con-ron come with a formal proof, relative to set theory, that they cannot accept a false proof, thus addressing concerns that Lean’s logic itself might have flaws that the proof could exploit. An extensive overview is available at https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/. These checks ran on an inert export of the proof, out of reach of hypothetical malicious code in the Lean proof sources.

Valid point, but we should be able to trust something at some point I guess.

disclaimer; I have no acting knowledge of anything here.

load more comments (2 replies)
[–] xxce2AAb@feddit.dk 20 points 20 hours ago (2 children)
[–] 2ndDegreeOWO@lemmy.world 6 points 18 hours ago (9 children)

It'll be another hallucinated solution, most likely. With very little press given when some actual mathematician debunks it a month later.

[–] NoneOfUrBusiness@fedia.io 7 points 7 hours ago

What do you mean "another"? Did it hallucinate a famous proof recently?

load more comments (8 replies)
[–] one_old_coder@piefed.social 31 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (1 children)

Or the AI stole the credits from this guy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50579568 "It is all human, with no AI"

load more comments (1 replies)
[–] GreenKnight23@lemmy.world 5 points 18 hours ago

I can't wait to hear about this guy smearing his shit on the walls of an IHop bathroom while he screams about how right he was.

[–] poccalyps@sh.itjust.works 27 points 1 day ago (2 children)

“Anthropic mathematician” 🤣🤣🤣

[–] NoneOfUrBusiness@fedia.io 4 points 7 hours ago

I mean yes? Anthropic does employ mathematicians.

load more comments (1 replies)
load more comments
view more: next ›