MarxMadness

When have U.S. troops fought against imperialism?

And if you're hanging your hat on (reluctantly) being on the right side of one war 80 years ago, it's time for a hard look in the mirror.

as an unremarkable captain of an unremarkable country on the fascist side of WWII (why him?)

there weren’t a ton of capable and experienced officers back then in the army.

This seems like a great answer to "why him?"

I don’t see the point that is trying to be made here

A common anti-communist narrative is that communist governments are not actually popular. The main point of highlighting CIA involvement with various "popular" opposition groups is that this narrative is heavily astroturfed.

A secondary point is that all the anti-communist stories about repression and show trials should be read in the light that yes, a hostile foreign government was in fact working with your domestic opposition groups to try to overthrow your government.

Enforcement is an inseparable part of the rule of law. If laws aren't enforced at all, your "laws" aren't anything more than moral judgments. If laws aren't enforced equally, you don't have a "rule" of law so much as a set of state-sanctioned persecutions.

There's a lot more to the topic than just enforcement, but to claim enforcement is anything but a crucial part of the mix is nonsensical.

A U.S. Supreme Court case on sterilization was cited by the defense at the Nuremberg Trials: Buck v. Bell.

"I'm not insulting you, I'm just saying you're writing word salad devoid of substance like a notorious quack"

What communist country did you personally live under, lemmy user in 2025?

I'll also point out that tons of people all over the world are ignorant of how their own countries operate.

China is an extremely rapidly developing country that was as poor as Haiti is today 100 years ago.

I'd say 75, at the end of the Civil War. The firsthand descriptions of rural China from Fanshen come from around that period and are basically late-feudal, but ravaged by a few decades of major wars.

I’m American they would have us believe that the average Chinese citizen is living one step of from a factory slave.

Download RedNote and see for yourself. You'll never get a full picture from social media alone, but you can see a lot.

you can have a bit of capitalism and a bit of socialism in a healthy mix of free trade economy with regulations

I used to believe this, and I also used to argue against socialists on the same exact grounds.

At some point I noticed that all those nice little bits of socialism that rounded off the edges of capitalism kept getting rolled back. Then I read more about how those safety nets were put up in the first place -- I found out they were all bought with the blood of people much farther left than me, and I saw how violently capitalists opposed them. I found that a lot of the reason those safety nets were so nice for so long in the Global North was that our countries were slaughtering people by the millions (again, a lot of leftists) elsewhere in the world to prop capitalism up.

At that point I stopped just nodding along to all the campfire stories about socialist countries. Maybe, like my standard U.S. education had missed a lot of pretty important things about how capitalism works, it had similarly missed some important things about how socialism works.

That's good work for a lot of reasons, but there's a world of difference between "open source and theoretically DIY" and it being anywhere near realistic for everyone to actually do it themselves.

It's good that I have access to advanced technology without having to have learned how to build it from the ground up. That's the whole point of civilization -- doing more together than we could do apart.

Regarding gulags, it’s the same as telling me about concentration camps built by the Nazis.

From a researcher who actually examined Soviet archives after the fall of the USSR in the 90s (PDF link, see pg. 1041):

Even in the terrible year of 1937, 44.4 percent of the GULAG labor camp population on January 1 was freed during the course of the year.

These weren't death camps, these were prisons. You can read elsewhere in the same article about how most of the people in them had been convicted of non-political crimes every country in the world prosecutes. Just like in many other countries, people would serve their sentence and be released.

The article also notes how the vast majority of mortality in the Soviet prison system was attributable to the hardships imposed by WWII (also from pg. 1041):

More than half of all GULAG deaths in the entire 1934-1953 period occurred in 1941-1943, mostly from malnutrition.

Comparing this to the Nazi system that was directly designed to exterminate people is no more than roundabout Nazi apologia.

The USSR’s implementation of communism was so bad, it’s become cliche.

So bad that after the fall of the Soviet Union, its former republics all had an immediate, sustained downturn in their quality of life, and a corresponding uptick in mortality.